Explainer
Who’s doing what — California weather modification
Winter orographic cloud seeding — releasing ice-forming particles into already stormy clouds so more water freezes and falls as snow or rain — has been practiced in California since the early 1950s. It is a reported water-supply tool run by irrigation districts, water agencies, and utilities. Separately, NOAA and EPA records also name a private sulfur-dioxide balloon company that is actively deploying (Make Sunsets), an Israeli–U.S. company building an aircraft SAI system that has not deployed (Stardust Solutions), and a University of Washington sea-salt spray test on the USS Hornet in Alameda. Those are different actors, substances, and means. None of this is secret spraying, and none of it is the white streaks behind jets.
Open the California weather-modification map. Filter by company / operator and by means. Pins are published sites. Shaded boxes are approximate project or reported-region areas. Amounts and methods appear only when a cited report states them.
On this page: Why agencies and PG&E seed · Who pays · Program detail · Dated list · Directory
Three different activities — do not merge them
| Who | Means | Substance | Purpose | Alameda? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water agencies, irrigation districts, PG&E, and contractors (NAWC, WMI, RHS) | Ground CNG / AHOGS; aircraft flares | Silver iodide (AgI) | Local precipitation / snowpack for water and hydro | No. Sierra and Southern California watersheds. |
| Make Sunsets, Inc. (Luke Iseman, Andrew Song)Actively deploying | High-altitude balloons | Sulfur dioxide (SO₂) | Stratospheric aerosol injection / “cooling credits” | No. Published HQ is Box Elder, South Dakota. NPR reported a late-2023 launch from a Silicon Valley-outskirts parking lot (San Jose dateline). Exact lots unpublished. |
| Stardust SolutionsR&D / prep for tests — not deploying | Aircraft dispersion systems (in development) | Proprietary reflective particles (amorphous silica described in May 2026 papers) | Sell a government SAI capability ~end of decade; says it will not unilaterally deploy | No published CA site — not plotted. Delaware- incorporated; HQ / lab outside Tel Aviv (Ness Ziona). Not Make Sunsets and not the Hornet test. |
| University of Washington MCB Program, with SRI International and SilverLining | Marine cloud brightening spray (CARI) | Sea salt / salt water | Research on aerosol–cloud processes | Yes — this is the Alameda project. USS Hornet, 707 W Hornet Ave, Pier 3. City council rejected restart June 4, 2024. |
A reader who heard “Alameda” and “weather modification” together is almost certainly thinking of the Hornet sea-salt test, not Make Sunsets. Primary sources put Make Sunsets’ office at 514 Americas Way #18412, Box Elder, SD 57719 (company contact page and the EPA §114 letter). The two projects share a NOAA reporting statute, not an operator, substance, or launch site.
Commercial SAI / SRM — two companies, different status
Public reporting on for-profit stratospheric aerosol injection is essentially two companies. This site does not invent a third. EPA’s geoengineering FAQ (as of July 2025) said the U.S. government is not doing outdoor solar-geoengineering testing or large-scale deployment, and that EPA was then aware of only one private-sector actor — Make Sunsets — that had actively deployed SAI or MCB in the United States. The same FAQ noted that a few other private actors were developing different solar-geoengineering technologies. Stardust is the other commercial name that later reporting treats as the serious builder (aircraft + proprietary particles), not a balloon deployer.
- Make Sunsets, Inc. — deploying. High-altitude SO₂ balloons; sells cooling credits; NOAA Form 17-4 on file; EPA Clean Air Act §114 demand April 2025. Founder said California and Nevada launches; exact lots often unpublished. Mapped as an approximate South Bay box only.
- Stardust Solutions — R&D, not deploying. Israeli–U.S. for-profit, Delaware-incorporated, headquarters outside Tel Aviv (stardustsrt.com). Developing aircraft systems to disperse proprietary reflective particles — not SO₂ balloons. About $75 million raised ($15 million seed + $60 million in October 2025 led by Lowercarbon Capital: Heatmap, Axios, POLITICO/E&E). Indoor work; October 2025 reporting described “outdoor contained” tests as soon as April 2026 with particles inside a modified plane at about 18 km — not an open free release. The Atlantic (April 2, 2026) wrote that the company said it has no outdoor tests planned until relevant regulations exist. No public California coordinates, so there is no map pin.
- Not SAI companies: California cloud seeding (silver iodide, water agencies) is a separate precipitation tool. The UW Hornet test is marine cloud brightening with sea salt — research, city-blocked restart. Academic proposals such as Harvard’s cancelled SCoPEx balloon experiment are not commercial deployers and are not on this California map.
Dated efforts — newest first
A reference list of reported California weather-modification activity with a published date or season, sorted by that date descending. After- action months (Form 17-4A / agency annual) are not mixed up with Form 17-4 prior notice. If a source only names a season, that is what the date column says. Calendar days appear only when a cited report names them — Mokelumne’s November 2025 17-4A, for example, says one modification day without naming the day of the month.
| Date | What this date is | Operator | Means / substance | Location | Amount | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 14, 2026 — company posted SAI research papers | Company R&D / funding (not a CA spray day) | Stardust Solutions | Aircraft-dispersal R&D (papers, not a CA field release)Engineered amorphous silica particles (company preprint titles) | No published California test site | Not a deployment total — laboratory / preprint research | Stardust Solutions — publications listed on company site (May 14, 2026) |
| April 2, 2026 — company said it has no outdoor tests planned | Company R&D / funding (not a CA spray day) | Stardust Solutions | R&D / indoor and modeling path (not open stratospheric release)Proprietary reflective particles | No published California test site | The Atlantic: Stardust said it will not conduct outdoor tests until relevant regulations exist | The Atlantic, Apr. 2, 2026 |
| November 2025 (1 modification day; calendar day not named) | After-action (seeded / sprayed) | Pacific Gas and Electric Company | Ground generators (CNG)Silver iodide | Mokelumne River watershed (Central Sierra) | 1 seeded day, 83 ground hours, 1,760 g AgI. Same 17-4A: December 2025 = 0 days. | NOAA Form 17-4A 2026CAMOKE-2 (certified Jan. 28, 2026; period Nov. 1–Dec. 31, 2025) |
| 2025–26 season noticed Nov. 1, 2025–Apr. 30, 2026 (prior notice only) | Prior notice only (Form 17-4) | Weather Modification International (WMI) for TID / MID | Aircraft flaresSilver iodide | Tuolumne River watershed | No posted 17-4A with seeded days or grams for this season | NOAA Form 17-4 2026WYUT-1 (signed Oct. 9, 2025) |
| October 24, 2025 — $60 million raise (~$75 million total) | Company R&D / funding (not a CA spray day) | Stardust Solutions | Aircraft SAI system in development (not SO₂ balloons)Proprietary particles (later papers: amorphous silica) | Delaware-incorporated; HQ outside Tel Aviv / Ness Ziona — not a CA pin | $60M led by Lowercarbon Capital; prior $15M seed. POLITICO/E&E: contained in-aircraft tests discussed for as soon as April 2026 (particles inside a plane at ~18 km — not free release). | Heatmap and POLITICO/E&E, Oct. 24, 2025 |
| 2025–26 season noticed Nov. 1, 2025–May 31, 2026 (prior notice only) | Prior notice only (Form 17-4) | Pacific Gas and Electric Company | Ground generators (CNG)Silver iodide | Mokelumne River watershed | Form 17-4 states 21.5 g AgI/hour; after-action grams are on 2026CAMOKE-2 | NOAA Form 17-4 2026CAMOKE-1 (signed Oct. 21, 2025) |
| July 10, 2025 — program concluded | Program ended | NAWC for SAWPA | Ground CNG and AHOGSSilver iodide | Santa Ana River Watershed | No 2025–26 season | SAWPA public notice — Cloud Seeding Program Concludes |
| As of May 2025 (EPA compilation — not a named CA launch day) | As of a published report | Make Sunsets, Inc. | High-altitude balloonsSulfur dioxide | U.S. deployments; CA lots unpublished (South Bay / Silicon Valley region reported) | About 0.1 tons SO₂ as of the EPA Government Action page | EPA Government Action (geoengineering) |
| April 15, 2025 — WY2025 operations finished | Season ended | RHS Consulting (2024 Form 17-4) / KRCD program | Aircraft and ground generatorsSilver iodide | Kings River basin above Pine Flat | Season grams not posted; KRCD was waiting on the WY2025 final report | KRCD chief engineer report (WY2025 operations ended Apr. 15, 2025) |
| April 15, 2025 — EPA information demand | As of a published report | Make Sunsets, Inc. | High-altitude balloonsSulfur dioxide | Launch locations unclear to EPA; founder later named California and Nevada | Company website then stated more than 124 deployments | EPA news release — CAA §114 demand (Apr. 15, 2025) |
| December 2024 (1 modification day; calendar day not named) | After-action (seeded / sprayed) | Pacific Gas and Electric Company | Ground generators (CNG)Silver iodide | Mokelumne River watershed | 1 day / 98 hours / 2,051 g AgI | NOAA Form 17-4A FY25 Q3 2025CAMOKE-1 (Nov. 1–Dec. 31, 2024) |
| December 2024 — 0 seeded days (noticed 2024–25 season) | After-action (0 days) | NAWC for Santa Barbara County Water Agency | Ground AHOGSSilver iodide | Twitchell / Huasna–Alamo | 0 g on the December 2024 17-4A | NOAA Form 17-4A FY25 Q2 2025CASB-1 |
| November 2024 (2 modification days; calendar days not named) | After-action (seeded / sprayed) | Pacific Gas and Electric Company | Ground generators (CNG)Silver iodide | Mokelumne River watershed | 2 days / 139 hours / 2,921 g AgI | NOAA Form 17-4A FY25 Q3 2025CAMOKE-1 |
| 2024–25 season noticed Nov. 15, 2024–Apr. 30, 2025 (prior notice only) | Prior notice only (Form 17-4) | Weather Modification International (WMI) for TID / MID | Aircraft flaresSilver iodide | Tuolumne River watershed | No posted 17-4A with seeded days or grams for that season | NOAA Form 17-4 2025WYUT-1 |
| June 4, 2024 — city rejected restart | Government action | University of Washington MCB Program (host: USS Hornet / City of Alameda landlord) | Marine cloud brightening spray (CARI)Sea salt / salt water | USS Hornet, 707 W Hornet Ave, Pier 3, Alameda | No restart after this vote | City of Alameda statement (June 5, 2024) |
| 2023–24 Twitchell season (Dec. 1, 2023–Mar. 31, 2024, plus early April 2024) | Published season | NAWC for Santa Barbara County Water Agency | Ground AHOGS (ground only that season)Silver iodide | Twitchell / Huasna–Alamo (Santa Ynez not seeded) | Estimated 3,180 g AgI from 159 flares; 14 storm events on 19 calendar days | Santa Barbara County / NAWC Annual Cloud Seeding Report 2023–24 |
| 2023–24 season (Nov. 15, 2023–Apr. 15, 2024) | Published season | NAWC for SAWPA | Ground CNG and AHOGSSilver iodide | Santa Ana River Watershed (15 published sites) | 17,082 g AgI from CNG hours; 640 g from 32 AHOGS flares; 13 seeded storms over 22 days | SAWPA Annual Cloud Seeding Report 2023–24 |
| March 26–28, April 2–3, and April 5, 2024 | After-action (seeded / sprayed) | University of Washington MCB Program | Marine cloud brightening spray (CARI)Sea salt / salt water | USS Hornet flight deck, Alameda | Each named spray under 3 minutes (hearing coverage); EPA FAQ: about 20 minutes before shutdown. No sea-salt gram total on 2024CACARE-1. | NOAA Form 17-4 2024CACARE-1; City of Alameda File 2024-4063; Alameda Post quoting Doherty at the June 2024 hearing |
| 2023–24 winter noticed through Mar. 31, 2024 | Prior notice only (Form 17-4) | RHS Consulting, Ltd. | Aircraft and ground generatorsSilver iodide | Kings River Basin | Planned rates on the 17-4 (800–3,000 g/hr air; 20 g/hr ground); season grams not on that form | NOAA Form 17-4 2024WYKI-1 |
| December 2023 (1 modification day; calendar day not named) | After-action (seeded / sprayed) | Pacific Gas and Electric Company | Ground generators (CNG)Silver iodide | Mokelumne River watershed | 1 day / 66 hours / 1,422 g AgI | NOAA Form 17-4A 2024CAMOKE-1 (Nov. 1–Dec. 31, 2023) |
| Late 2023 (calendar day unpublished) | As of a published report | Make Sunsets, Inc. | High-altitude balloonsSulfur dioxide | Parking lot on the outskirts of Silicon Valley (NPR; San Jose dateline) | No posted CA 17-4A gram total for that launch | NPR, Apr. 21, 2024 |
| Water Year 2020 winter season (DWR citation) | Published season | RHS Consulting (as cited by DWR for a SMUD-submitted report) | Not specified in the DWR RMS paragraphNot named in the DWR RMS paragraph | Upper American River basin | Grams not published in the RMS; DWR quotes streamflow-increase estimates only | DWR Precipitation Enhancement RMS (cites SMUD 2020 / RHS) |
| Since 1990 (TID program start) | Long-running program (start year) | Now WMI (2025–26 17-4s); sponsors TID and MID | Aircraft flaresSilver iodide | Tuolumne River watershed | No season gram total on the TID page used here | Turlock Irrigation District — Cloud Seeding |
| Since 1981 (county MND) | Long-running program (start year) | NAWC for Santa Barbara County Water Agency | Ground AHOGS; aircraft in some seasonsSilver iodide | Santa Barbara County / Twitchell / Santa Ynez | See 2023–24 season row for the last published gram total | Santa Barbara County and Twitchell Reservoir Cloud Seeding Program (WMA / CEQA MND) |
| Since water year 1954–55 | Long-running program (start year) | KRCD program (RHS on the 2024 17-4; NAWC in some earlier years) | Aircraft and groundSilver iodide | Kings River basin | Historic; recent season grams not posted | KRCD / Griffith et al., Journal of Weather Modification |
| Since 1953 (Almanor and Mokelumne) | Long-running program (start year) | Pacific Gas and Electric Company | Ground generatorsSilver iodide | Lake Almanor and Mokelumne watersheds | See Mokelumne 17-4A rows for posted gram months | DWR Precipitation Enhancement RMS |
Full directory of named companies and operators
Every CA-relevant name found in the NOAA filings, DWR / agency reports, EPA pages, and WMA assessments used for this site — not a short sample. Role is listed as operator, sponsor, contractor, site host, funder, host, or government tracker. If someone appears only as a funder, that is said. This roster can still be incomplete: NOAA’s public archive lags, and GAO found underreporting. It does not omit known names to stay short.
41 named entities in this compilation, grouped by role. Click a name to open the matching map filter where a feature exists.
Operators and contractors
| Name | Role | Means | Substance | Purpose | Years / status | Location / target | Funding | Sources / map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| North American Weather Consultants (NAWC) | Operator / contractor | Ground CNG and AHOGS; aircraft in some Santa Barbara seasons | Silver iodide | Precipitation enhancement for sponsor water agencies | Santa Barbara / Twitchell since 1981 (county MND); SAWPA 2023–24 season (pilot ended July 10, 2025); JWM also lists NAWC on Kings in some earlier water years | Santa Ana watershed (15 published sites); Santa Barbara / Twitchell / Santa Ynez (6 published AHOGS) | Paid by SAWPA / SBCWA and partner agencies — not a self-funded operator |
|
| RHS Consulting, Ltd. (Richard Stone) | Operator / contractor | Aircraft plus ground generators (Kings 2024WYKI-1); method for SMUD 2020 not specified in DWR RMS | Silver iodide | Precipitation / snowpack for sponsor districts | Kings River Form 17-4 2024WYKI-1 (through Mar. 31, 2024); DWR cites RHS on SMUD WY2020 report | Kings River Basin (2,225 sq mi target on the 17-4); upper American (DWR citation only) | Paid by KRCD / KRWA and, as cited, SMUD — not a self-funded operator | |
| Atmospherics, Inc. | Historic operator (not current on the 2024 17-4) | Not specified for a current season in sources used here | Silver iodide (historic Kings program) | Historic Kings River seeding | JWM: historic Kings operator before later NAWC / RHS seasons | Kings River | Historic contractor — not listed as 2024 operator | |
| Weather Modification LLC dba Weather Modification International (WMI) | Operator / contractor | Aircraft pyrotechnic AgI flares | Silver iodide | Augment snowpack / precipitation in the Tuolumne River Watershed | Named on NOAA Form 17-4 2025WYUT-1 and 2026WYUT-1 (Jody Fischer / Jake Van Ornum) | Upper Tuolumne (675 sq mi target on 2025WYUT-1); no published generator sites (aircraft) | Paid by TID and MID | |
| Carson / Walker River winter program (listed) | Listed program — current operator not confirmed | Not specified for a current season in the sources used here | Not published for a current season | Snowpack augmentation on the eastern Sierra Carson/Walker drainages (as listed in WMA program assessments) | Listed in WMA economic assessments; no current-season California 17-4 compiled here | Approximate California-side Walker / Carson crest (map box). Eastern Sierra programs also operate in Nevada. | Not confirmed for a current season |
Sponsors, utilities, and water agencies
| Name | Role | Means | Substance | Purpose | Years / status | Location / target | Funding | Sources / map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Santa Ana Watershed Project Authority (SAWPA) | Sponsor / program lead | Ground CNG and AHOGS (no aircraft in 2023–24) | Silver iodide | Runoff and snowpack in the Santa Ana River Watershed | Four-year pilot; 2023–24 operations Nov. 15, 2023–Apr. 15, 2024; concluded July 10, 2025 | Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino, Los Angeles (watershed) | ~$1.2M planned four-year pilot; ~half DWR grant (state taxpayer), remainder split among five member agencies (LA Times Daily Pilot Jan. 2024). Ended July 10, 2025. | |
| Santa Barbara County Water Agency (Public Works) | Sponsor | Ground AHOGS; aircraft in some seasons (not 2023–24) | Silver iodide | Increase runoff into Twitchell Reservoir and, when active, Lake Cachuma / Santa Ynez | NAWC programs since 1981; last confirmed seeded days early April 2024 | Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo (Twitchell / Santa Ynez targets) | Recent press: ~$370k/year; County Water Agency ~50%, rest ~nine purveyors (Noozhawk / SLO Tribune / Independent). 2018–19 NAWC contract NTE $146,500 (county File 18-00807). |
|
| Kings River Conservation District | Sponsor | Aircraft plus ground generators (2024WYKI-1) | Silver iodide | Inflow to Pine Flat Reservoir | Operational winter program since water year 1954–55; KRCD: WY2025 operations finished Apr. 15, 2025 | Kings River watershed above Pine Flat (approximate box; no published generator coordinates) | KRCD board-approved 2023–24 budget $475,597 (KRCD notice), with KRWA and PG&E as collaborators. Local public-agency money. | |
| Kings River Water Association | Sponsor / historic supporter | Same Kings program (aircraft + ground) | Silver iodide | Kings River water supply | Long-running winter program with KRCD | Kings River Basin | Named with KRCD on program materials; WMA economic paper lists KRWA among supporters | |
| Turlock Irrigation District | Sponsor | Aircraft AgI flares (WMI) | Silver iodide | Irrigation, environmental flows, and hydropower on the Tuolumne | TID page: program began 1990; 2026WYUT-1 notices Nov. 1, 2025–Apr. 30, 2026 | Tuolumne River watershed | CNBC Dec. 2022: TID program maximum budget $475,000. Older press: ~$165–170k/year TID+MID (SF Chronicle; Turlock Journal). Irrigation-district / ratepayer money. | |
| Modesto Irrigation District | Sponsor | Aircraft AgI flares (WMI) | Silver iodide | Tuolumne River watershed with TID | Named with TID on 2025 and 2026 Form 17-4s (Jason Carkeet) | Tuolumne River watershed | TID and MID | |
| Pacific Gas and Electric Company | Operator and sponsor | Ground CNG / radio-controlled propane-acetone AgI generators (Mokelumne: seven named burners, no published coordinates). Almanor: ground-based AgI generators. | Silver iodide (Mokelumne 17-4 also names ammonia iodide in the generator description) | Increase useful precipitation for hydroelectric / water (Almanor, Mokelumne) | DWR: both programs ongoing since 1953. Newest posted after-action: Mokelumne Nov. 2025 (2026CAMOKE-2) | Lake Almanor / Butt Valley / Mountain Meadows; Mokelumne (Calaveras, Amador, Alpine). Operator meteorologist listed San Ramon; sponsor address 300 Lakeside Drive, Oakland on the 17-4. | Investor-owned utility. Budget not published in DWR RMS, NOAA 17-4s, or CPUC filings used here. SF Chronicle (2015) said PG&E described costs as a couple hundred thousand a year and declined a specific amount. | |
| East Bay Municipal Utility District | Historic supporter (not listed as current operator) | Not specified as a current-season operator in sources used here | Silver iodide (Mokelumne program context) | Historic support of the Mokelumne winter program (WMA paper) | Listed in a WMA economic assessment — not on the 2025–26 Form 17-4 as operator | Mokelumne watershed (PG&E project) | Historic supporter per WMA paper | |
| Sacramento Municipal Utility District | Sponsor (as cited by DWR) | Not specified in the DWR RMS paragraph that cites the 2020 report | Silver iodide | Streamflow / precipitation augmentation in the upper American River basin | DWR RMS cites a Water Year 2020 winter-season report (SMUD / RHS). Current-season status not confirmed there. | Approximate upper American / Folsom contributing area | SMUD (as cited) | |
| Southern California Edison | Historic sponsor (listed; current season not confirmed) | Not specified for a current season | Silver iodide (WMA San Joaquin listing context) | WMA tables have listed SCE among historic San Joaquin winter-program sponsors | Listed in WMA assessments; no current-season 17-4 compiled here | Approximate upper San Joaquin / Millerton contributing area | Not confirmed for a current season |
Site hosts and landlords
| Name | Role | Means | Substance | Purpose | Years / status | Location / target | Funding | Sources / map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chino Basin Water Conservation District (WCD) | Site host | Ground CNG (hosted generators) | Silver iodide | Host sites for SAWPA / NAWC generators (NW1 Montclair #4; NW2 Upland/College Heights). Table 2-2 abbreviation is Chino Basin WCD — not the Chino Basin Watermaster. | 2023–24 SAWPA season | San Bernardino County (published Table 2-2 sites) | SAWPA pilot host — not listed as the operator | |
| San Antonio Water Company | Site host | Ground CNG (hosted generators) | Silver iodide | Host sites NW3 East and NW4 West | 2023–24 SAWPA season | San Bernardino County (published Table 2-2) | SAWPA pilot host | |
| San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District | Site host | Ground CNG | Silver iodide | Host site NE7 Highland/Summertrail Place | 2023–24 SAWPA season | San Bernardino County | SAWPA pilot host | |
| San Bernardino Valley Water Conservation District | Site host | Ground CNG | Silver iodide | Host sites NE8 Mentone/Mill Creek and NE9 Santa Ana Dam | 2023–24 SAWPA season | San Bernardino County | SAWPA pilot host | |
| San Gorgonio Pass Water Agency | Site host | Ground CNG | Silver iodide | Host site NE10 Cherry Valley | 2023–24 SAWPA season | Riverside County | SAWPA pilot host | |
| Eastern Municipal Water District | Site host | AHOGS and remote CNG | Silver iodide | Host sites SE11 Balher Booster (AHOGS) and SE12 Searle Tank II (remote CNG) | 2023–24 SAWPA season | Riverside County | SAWPA pilot host | |
| El Toro Water District | Site host | AHOGS | Silver iodide | Host site SW14 Reservoir | 2023–24 SAWPA season | Orange County | SAWPA pilot host | |
| East Orange County Water District | Site host | AHOGS | Silver iodide | Host site SW15 EOCWD | 2023–24 SAWPA season | Orange County | SAWPA pilot host | |
| San Bernardino – Sycamore WP (SAWPA Table 2-2 host name) | Site host (named in SAWPA Table 2-2; agency legal name not expanded there) | Ground CNG | Silver iodide | Host site NE5 Sycamore WP | 2023–24 SAWPA season | San Bernardino County (published Table 2-2) | SAWPA pilot host | |
| Rimforest (SAWPA Table 2-2 site name) | Site host (named in SAWPA Table 2-2; host organization not named beyond the site) | Ground CNG | Silver iodide | Host site NE6 Rimforest | 2023–24 SAWPA season | San Bernardino County (published Table 2-2) | SAWPA pilot host — Table 2-2 does not name a separate water-agency owner for this pin | |
| Lakeshore (SAWPA Table 2-2 site name) | Site host (named in SAWPA Table 2-2; host organization not named beyond the site) | Ground CNG | Silver iodide | Host site SE13 Lakeshore | 2023–24 SAWPA season | Riverside County (published Table 2-2) | SAWPA pilot host — Table 2-2 does not name a separate water-agency owner for this pin | |
| Aircraft Carrier Hornet Foundation / USS Hornet Sea, Air & Space Museum | Host site / lessee — not the research operator | Hosted the CARI spray on the flight deck; did not file as the weather-modification operator | Sea salt (hosted) | Museum host. City staff: Hornet staff had not realized City approval was required under the lease. | March–April 2024; city ordered halt; June 4, 2024 consent denied | 707 W Hornet Ave, Pier 3, Alameda. Lease with City of Alameda dated March 15, 2009 (File 2024-4063). | Host, not funder of SAI/MCB research |
|
| City of Alameda | Landlord / local government (shut down MCB; not an operator) | No weather-modification apparatus | n/a | Landlord for Pier 3. Instructed a halt; June 4, 2024 council unanimously rejected landlord consent to restart sea-salt studies. | May 2024 halt; June 4–5, 2024 council action / statement | Alameda Point / Pier 3 | n/a |
Solar geoengineering / research field work
| Name | Role | Means | Substance | Purpose | Years / status | Location / target | Funding | Sources / map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Make Sunsets, Inc. | Operator (private SAI company — actively deploying) | High-altitude balloons releasing sulfur dioxide | Sulfur dioxide (SO₂). 2023 Form 17-4 OCR also mentions calcium carbonate and other proprietary materials — quoted only as a handwritten filing, not as a confirmed 17-4A total. | Stratospheric aerosol injection / “cooling credits” (solar radiation modification), not precipitation seeding. EPA FAQ (as of July 2025): only private-sector actor EPA then knew had actively deployed SAI or MCB in the United States. | Founded 2022. NOAA 17-4 2023wmainitial on file. EPA §114 demand Apr. 15, 2025. Company FAQ still claims yearly NOAA reporting as of 2026. | HQ: 514 Americas Way #18412, Box Elder, SD 57719 (company contact + EPA letter) — not Alameda. NPR: late-2023 launch from a parking lot on the outskirts of Silicon Valley (San Jose dateline). Founder told Inside Climate News: California and Nevada. Exact lots unpublished. Mexico Baja launches in 2022 led Mexico to announce a planned ban. | Cooling-credit sales; NPR 2024: >$1.2M from Boost VC, Pioneer Fund, Draper Associates |
|
| Stardust Solutions | Private SAI / SRM developer (R&D and test prep — not a deployer) | Aircraft dispersion systems for proprietary reflective particles (not SO₂ balloons; not Make Sunsets) | Proprietary particles. Company / May 2026 preprints describe engineered amorphous silica (including a silica-coated / calcium-carbonate-core design). Exact commercial formulation was long undisclosed pending patent. | Build manufacturing, aircraft dispersal, and monitoring so governments could buy a sunlight-reflection capability — company says it will not unilaterally deploy at scale | Founded 2023. Indoor trials; $15M seed then $60M Oct. 24, 2025 (Lowercarbon Capital; ~$75M total). POLITICO/E&E (Oct. 2025): planned “outdoor contained” in-aircraft tests as soon as April 2026 at ~18 km, particles inside a modified plane — not open free release. The Atlantic (Apr. 2, 2026): company said it has no outdoor tests planned until relevant regulations exist. May 14, 2026: company posted research papers. No published California launch or test coordinates. | Delaware-incorporated U.S. company; HQ / lab outside Tel Aviv (Ness Ziona, Israel per MIT Technology Review / Wikipedia). MIT TR (Dec. 2025): planned to open a U.S. headquarters — location not published as California. No map pin: no public CA site. | ~$75 million: $15M seed (Awz Ventures / SolarEdge named in later summaries) + $60M Oct. 2025 led by Lowercarbon Capital (Heatmap, Axios, POLITICO/E&E) |
|
| Harvard SCoPEx (Stratospheric Controlled Perturbation Experiment) | Academic research proposal (not a commercial deployer; outdoor balloon trial cancelled) | Proposed small scientific balloon / gondola (not a company cooling-credit program) | Proposed calcium carbonate / scientific tracer amounts — never flown as the planned outdoor test | University research on stratospheric aerosols. Distinguishes academic SRM science from for-profit SAI companies. | Proposed 2010s–2020s; planned Sweden flight cancelled (2021); project later ended without the outdoor release | Not California. No pin on this map. | Academic / philanthropic research — not a CA weather-modification contractor | |
| University of Washington Marine Cloud Brightening Program | Research operator | Marine cloud brightening spray (CARI salt-water aerosol from the Hornet flight deck) | Sea salt / salt water — not SO₂, not silver iodide | Research on aerosol–cloud processes and marine cloud brightening. Separate from Make Sunsets. | NOAA 2024CACARE-1 (March 2024 plan). Sprays March–early April 2024. City halt; council rejected restart June 4, 2024. | USS Hornet, 707 W Hornet Ave, Pier 3, Alameda (published museum / NRHP coordinates) | SilverLining led fundraising (NPR: about $16 million for the UW program, mostly philanthropic). SRI International named as collaborators. EPA FAQ: NOAA and DOE modeling funds in 2021 — not stated as the Hornet spray budget. |
|
| SRI International | Instrument / field collaborator (not the sponsor water agency) | CARI sea-salt spray system (with UW) | Sea salt / salt water | Field measurements on the Hornet deck (2024CACARE-1 names Jessica Medrado and others, Palo Alto) | March–April 2024 Hornet test | Palo Alto affiliation on the 17-4 packet; field site Alameda (USS Hornet) | Collaborator on the UW / SilverLining MCB effort — not a cloud-seeding contractor |
|
Funders only (not operators)
| Name | Role | Means | Substance | Purpose | Years / status | Location / target | Funding | Sources / map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowercarbon Capital | Investor / funder (not an operator) | Does not operate SAI or cloud-seeding apparatus in the sources used here | n/a | Led Stardust’s $60 million October 2025 round (Heatmap, Axios) | October 2025 | n/a (investor; Wyoming-based firm per POLITICO/E&E) | Venture investment in Stardust (R&D, not a CA spray program) | |
| Boost VC | Investor / funder (not an operator) | Does not operate weather-modification apparatus in the sources used here | n/a | Named by NPR (2024) among Make Sunsets venture investors | NPR Apr. 21, 2024 | n/a (investor) | Venture investment in Make Sunsets | |
| Pioneer Fund | Investor / funder (not an operator) | Does not operate weather-modification apparatus in the sources used here | n/a | Named by NPR (2024) among Make Sunsets venture investors | NPR Apr. 21, 2024 | n/a (investor) | Venture investment in Make Sunsets | |
| Draper Associates | Investor / funder (not an operator) | Does not operate weather-modification apparatus in the sources used here | n/a | Named by NPR (2024) among Make Sunsets venture investors | NPR Apr. 21, 2024 | n/a (investor) | Venture investment in Make Sunsets | |
| SilverLining | Funder / collaborator (nonprofit) | Does not operate CA cloud-seeding generators in the sources used here | Sea salt (Hornet MCB context) | Led fundraising for the UW marine cloud brightening program (NPR) | Hornet test 2024; EPA FAQ also names SilverLining with UW and SRI | n/a (nonprofit collaborator); field site was Alameda | Philanthropic fundraising for UW MCB (NPR) |
|
Government reporting and oversight
| Name | Role | Means | Substance | Purpose | Years / status | Location / target | Funding | Sources / map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| California Department of Water Resources | State tracker / occasional funder — not day-to-day operator | Does not operate generators in the RMS description used here | Describes AgI as the standard CA agent; dry ice if aerial | Precipitation Enhancement Resource Management Strategy; statewide program context | RMS hosted at 2025 URL (Water Plan Update 2023 / Oct. 2024 imprint) | Statewide strategy, not a mapped project boundary | DWR estimates roughly $5–7 million a year on CA cloud-seeding operations (RMS). Does not directly fund day-to-day operations. SAWPA pilot: ~half of ~$1.2M from a DWR grant (Daily Pilot). | |
| NOAA (Office of Oceanic and Atmospheric Research / Weather Program Office) | Federal reporting archive — does not license or operate these projects | Collects Forms 17-4 / 17-4A; does not run generators, balloons, or MCB spray | n/a | Weather Modification Reporting Act of 1972. 15 CFR § 908.3 includes solar-radiation modification / aerosol release as well as classic cloud seeding. | Ongoing statutory program | Reports emailed to weather.modification@noaa.gov; public library of PDFs | Federal reporting program (not a project funder on this map except EPA’s note of 2021 modeling funds to UW) | |
| U.S. Environmental Protection Agency | Clean Air Act information demand (not an operator) | No EPA outdoor SRM deployment. EPA FAQ: U.S. government is not engaged in outdoor solar geoengineering testing or large-scale deployment. | n/a (asked Make Sunsets about SO₂) | Apr. 15, 2025 Office of Air and Radiation CAA §114 demand to Make Sunsets. FAQ (as of July 2025): only private actor EPA then knew had actively deployed SAI or MCB in the United States; other private actors were developing technologies. | Letter dated Apr. 14, 2025; news release Apr. 15, 2025; FAQ language as of July 2025 | Letter addressed to Box Elder, SD HQ | n/a |
This is not contrails
NOAA’s weather-modification library FAQ answers the question “What if I see streaks in the sky and I think someone is modifying the weather?” directly: those streaks are contrails — condensed combustion products and water vapor from aircraft at high, cold altitudes, observed since the early jet age. NOAA does not regulate airplane exhaust. The EPA sets aircraft emission standards; the FAA administers them. Cloud seeding, by contrast, is a separately reported activity: NOAA must receive Form 17-4 at least 10 days before starting, and operators file Form 17-4A after operations. The map on this site plots those reported programs, not flight tracks.
Source: NOAA Central Library — Weather Modification Project Reports (FAQ: “What if I see streaks in the sky…”).
Most-used substance: silver iodide
California and other western U.S. winter programs almost always use silver iodide (AgI). DWR’s Precipitation Enhancement Resource Management Strategy says projects “generally use silver iodide as the active seeding agent, supplemented by dry ice if aerial seeding is done.” Silver iodide can be released from ground generators or from airplanes. DWR also notes that liquid propane has occasionally been used, and that some recent projects have applied hygroscopic (water- attracting) materials as supplemental agents.
SAWPA’s 2023–24 annual report states that silver iodide was selected “for its environmental safety and superior efficiency in producing ice in clouds,” and that AgI particles have a structural similarity to natural ice. Santa Barbara County’s 2023–24 NAWC report describes high-output silver iodide complex flares at AHOGS sites (about 20 grams of AgI per flare that season). TID’s public program page describes aircraft flares that emit silver-iodide particles.
Dry ice (solid carbon dioxide) and other agents appear in DWR’s general description of California practice. This compilation did not find a California NOAA filing or agency annual report that published a dry-ice tonnage for a recent mapped season, so dry ice is not shown as a separate mapped substance. If a Form 17-4 names another agent, it belongs on the map only after that filing is cited.
Sources: DWR Precipitation Enhancement RMS; SAWPA 2023–24 annual report; Santa Barbara County / NAWC 2023–24 annual report; TID cloud seeding.
Why water agencies and PG&E cloud-seed
Almost every California pin on this map is winter orographic cloud seeding — silver iodide released into storms that are already hitting the mountains. That is a different activity from balloon or aircraft solar radiation modification (Make Sunsets, Stardust R&D). Water agencies and PG&E publish the same purpose in their own reports: grow snowpack or rain so more water later reaches reservoirs, canals, and — for the utility — hydroelectric plants.
Purpose: more runoff, not a statewide weather switch
The DWR Precipitation Enhancement Resource Management Strategy (Water Plan Update 2023, October 2024 imprint) is blunt: “In California, all precipitation enhancement projects are geared toward increasing water supply or hydroelectric power.” DWR describes winter orographic seeding — wind lifting moist air over mountains — as a way to add a modest amount of water to basins that already receive storms. Estimates of extra precipitation or runoff range from about 4% to 15%. DWR also says those percentages are hard to prove in any one year because weather varies so much, and that independent scientific confirmation of contractor claims is still limited.
Operators on this roster name the extra water for:
- Water supply for cities, farms, and groundwater recharge. SAWPA’s Santa Ana program is precipitation enhancement for runoff and snowpack. The Kings River notice targets inflow to Pine Flat Reservoir. Santa Barbara County Water Agency seeds watersheds that feed Twitchell, Cachuma, and Gibraltar so local reservoirs get more runoff.
- Irrigation, environmental flows, and hydropower on the same rivers. Turlock and Modesto Irrigation Districts describe the Tuolumne program as increasing snowpack for those three uses (TID program page).
- Hydroelectric generation in Sierra watersheds PG&E manages or benefits from. PG&E’s Lake Almanor and Mokelumne notices, and the matching NOAA Form 17-4 filings, state the purpose as increasing useful precipitation for hydroelectric / water. DWR notes both programs have run since 1953. That is more water through existing dams and powerhouses when snow melts — not a separate “climate engineering” fleet.
Agencies also argue it is cheaper than imported water when it works. Santa Barbara County hydrologist Matt Scrudato told Noozhawk the county program generated water at an estimated $80 per acre-foot — an agency / press claim, not a DWR audit. DWR’s own statewide cost range is about $20 to $40 per acre-foot of extra water, depending on the watershed and whether seeding is ground or aerial (RMS). Additional water from seeding is treated as natural supply for water-rights purposes, DWR writes.
Why winter storms in the mountains
California’s large programs are timed to winter orographic storms — moist air already being lifted over the Sierra Nevada, Transverse Ranges, or Peninsular Ranges. DWR: this has been practiced in California since the early 1950s. Ground generators (CNG or AHOGS) and, on some projects, aircraft release silver iodide into that existing cloud. The intended result is more snow in the high country that melts into streams in spring, or more rain in a coastal watershed that runs into a reservoir. PG&E’s current notices cover roughly November through May. That is drought-resilience and local supply augmentation in named basins — not an attempt to steer weather across the state. DWR notes that agencies often suspend seeding in wet years once enough snow has piled up.
What they are not doing
- Not SO₂ balloon SAI. Make Sunsets is a separate company selling cooling credits and filing under NOAA as solar-radiation modification. Water agencies and PG&E are not that program.
- Not secret spraying. Operators file NOAA Form 17-4 (prior notice) and 17-4A (after-action). DWR’s RMS adds California rules: an initial notice of intent, then every five years for continuing projects; some record-keeping; annual or biennial reports to DWR; CEQA review; and annual letter notices to affected county boards of supervisors. The Kings 2023–24 packet is one public example, and it lists PG&E as a collaborator on that river, not a covert sponsor.
- Not “controlling California’s weather.” The published purpose is incremental snow or rain in a named watershed so more of an existing storm becomes runoff later. DWR treats that as one small tool next to storage, conservation, and groundwater — not a statewide thermostat.
Who pays — and how much is public money
Dollar figures below appear only when a cited report or contemporaneous news story states them. They are not added up into a statewide total here. DWR’s own range is the only statewide number. Labels:
- State grant (taxpayer) — California DWR money. DWR’s RMS says it does not directly fund day-to-day operations; it tracks programs and recommends State support. The SAWPA pilot is the named recent grant.
- Local public agency / water district (ratepayer or local tax) — irrigation districts, county water agencies, joint-powers authorities, and their member purveyors. Paid from agency budgets that come from water rates, assessments, or local taxes.
- Investor-owned utility (ratepayer-regulated) — PG&E. This is not a state or federal spray budget. Costs sit in the utility’s hydro / water operations. That is not the same as a taxpayer line item, even though residential customers ultimately fund the utility.
- Private — Make Sunsets cooling-credit sales and venture money. Not public cloud-seeding funds.
Statewide (DWR)
DWR estimates roughly $5 million to $7 million a year on California cloud-seeding operations (RMS cost section). That is DWR’s statewide range, not a sum of the programs on this map. Federal money “has been scarce for the last 25 years,” DWR writes. Local agencies typically bundle costs or look to local bonds and water pricing. A hypothetical expansion that could add 500,000 to 700,000 acre-feet would take about $18 million up front plus about $8 million a year — DWR’s planning figure for more programs, not current yield.
Named program budgets
- SAWPA Santa Ana pilot — ~$1.2 million planned four-year cost. About half from a California DWR grant (state taxpayer / public funds). The remainder was split evenly among SAWPA’s five member public water agencies (local ratepayer / agency budgets). LA Times Daily Pilot, Jan. 13, 2024 (quoting SAWPA’s Jeff Mosher). SAWPA’s own FAQ also said the DWR grant covered half. The pilot concluded July 10, 2025 after year-1 validation found insufficient evidence of a significant precipitation increase, plus burn-scar debris-flow risk. Host sites in SAWPA Table 2-2 include Chino Basin Water Conservation District / WCD, San Antonio Water Company, San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District, San Bernardino Valley Water Conservation District, San Gorgonio Pass Water Agency, Eastern Municipal Water District, El Toro Water District, East Orange County Water District, and others.
- Santa Barbara County / Twitchell — about $370,000 a year in late-2022 coverage (Noozhawk; San Luis Obispo Tribune; Santa Barbara Independent, Dec. 29, 2022). County Water Agency about 50%; the rest split among about nine local water purveyors (Carpinteria, Montecito, Santa Barbara, Goleta, Santa Ynez Valley, Santa Maria, and others named in that coverage). Local public agency / ratepayer money. Contractor: NAWC, since 1981. Older board contract: 2018–19 NAWC agreement not to exceed $146,500 (County of Santa Barbara File 18-00807). The $80/acre-foot figure above is the county hydrologist’s cost-effectiveness claim in that same press, not a published audited yield.
- Kings River — $475,597 board-approved budget for the 2023–24 season starting Dec. 1, 2023, “in collaboration with Kings River Water Association and Pacific Gas and Electric” (ground generators plus up to 30 hours of aircraft). KRCD Weather Modification Program notice. Local public-agency money (KRCD / KRWA); PG&E is a collaborator, not the sole funder. A WMA economic paper also lists KRWA, PG&E, and DWR among historic supporters. That $475,597 is the approved project budget on that notice — not a claim that every dollar was spent.
- Tuolumne (TID / MID) — published as a maximum $475,000 in CNBC, Dec. 17, 2022, for Turlock’s program (3–5% runoff increase claimed in that story). Older local coverage put the shared TID + MID cost at about $165,000–$170,000 a year (San Francisco Chronicle; Turlock Journal— the Journal piece is from the program’s “22nd year,” so about 2012 if the start year is 1990). Local irrigation-district (ratepayer) money. Contractor: Weather Modification International. Current-season actual spend is not on the TID page used here.
- PG&E Lake Almanor and Mokelumne — budget not published in the DWR RMS, NOAA 17-4 / 17-4A PDFs, or CPUC filings used for this site. The San Francisco Chronicle (2015 drought coverage) wrote that PG&E’s program “costs a couple of hundred thousand dollars annually” and that the company declined to provide a specific amount. Treat that as a press paraphrase, not a published line item. Funder: investor-owned utility. A WMA paper lists East Bay Municipal Utility District among historic Mokelumne supporters.
- SMUD Upper American — current-season budget not published in the sources used here. DWR cites a Water Year 2020 SMUD / RHS Consulting winter report (streamflow-increase estimates only).
- Make Sunsets — private, not public cloud-seeding money. NPR (April 2024) reported more than $1.2 million from Boost VC, Pioneer Fund, and Draper Associates, plus cooling-credit sales. That does not fund PG&E or water-agency generators.
Major California programs
Status, means, and amounts only where a cited filing or agency report states them. “Listed” means a WMA or DWR mention without a current after-action report in this compilation.
Santa Ana River Watershed (SAWPA) — ended
Years: four-year pilot planned Nov. 15, 2023–Apr. 15, 2027; operated winter 2023–24; concluded July 10, 2025. Target: Santa Ana River Watershed (San Gabriel, San Bernardino, San Jacinto, and Santa Ana mountains). Means: ground CNG and AHOGS; no aircraft in 2023–24. Substance: silver iodide — 17,082 g from CNG hours and 640 g from 32 AHOGS flares; 13 seeded storms over 22 days (SAWPA 2023–24 annual). Operator: NAWC. Sponsors: SAWPA and member / host agencies. Money: ~$1.2 million planned; ~half DWR grant, rest five member agencies. Outcome: SAWPA said year-1 validation did not show a strong enough precipitation increase; 2024 burn scars would have forced another suspension.
Santa Barbara County / Twitchell — operating
Years: county Water Agency program since 1981 (research in the area dates earlier). Last confirmed seeded days: early April 2024 (2023–24 NAWC annual). Target: Twitchell Reservoir and, when active, Lake Cachuma / Santa Ynez / Gibraltar. Means: AHOGS (three active in 2023–24: Mt. Lospe, Harris Grade, Berros Peak) plus aircraft in some years; 2023–24 was ground-only. Substance: silver iodide — about 3,180 g from 159 flares; 14 storm events on 19 calendar days (2023–24 annual). Operator: NAWC. Sponsors: SBCWA plus local purveyors. Money: ~$370k/year in 2022 coverage; 2018–19 NTE $146,500. 2025CASB-1 noticed 2024–25; the only posted 17-4A (December 2024) is zero days.
Kings River (KRCD / KRWA) — operating
Years: 1954–55–present (KRCD / JWM histories); WY2025 operations ended Apr. 15, 2025 per KRCD. Target: Kings River inflow to Pine Flat Reservoir (2,225 sq mi on Form 17-4 2024WYKI-1). Means: aircraft plus ground silver-iodide generators (2023–24 notice: ground + up to 30 hours aircraft). Operator: RHS Consulting on the 2024 17-4. Sponsors: KRCD and KRWA; PG&E collaborator on the 2023–24 notice. Money: $475,597 board-approved 2023–24 budget. Season grams for WY2025 were not posted; KRCD said it was waiting on the final report.
Tuolumne River (TID / MID) — operating (noticed)
Years: TID since 1990; Form 17-4 2026WYUT-1 notices Nov. 1, 2025–Apr. 30, 2026. Target: Tuolumne River Watershed (675 sq mi on 2025WYUT-1). Means: aircraft AgI flares (WMI). Sponsors: Turlock and Modesto Irrigation Districts. Money: CNBC 2022 max $475,000; older press ~$165–170k/year. No posted 17-4A of actual 2025–26 days or grams. TID’s page claims a potential 5–15% precipitation increase and names irrigation, environmental flows, and hydropower as the uses.
PG&E Mokelumne — operating; newest posted seeding
Years: since 1953 (DWR / PG&E). Newest after-action: November 2025. Target: Mokelumne watershed, about 170 sq mi (Calaveras, Amador, Alpine). Means: seven ground-based, radio-controlled propane-acetone AgI generators at 21.5 g/hour (Form 17-4; site coordinates not published). Substance: November 2025 — 1 modification day, 83 ground hours, 1,760 g AgI (Form 17-4A 2026CAMOKE-2). December 2025: 0 days. Operator / sponsor: PG&E. Money: budget not published in sources used; Chronicle paraphrase “a couple of hundred thousand” / declined a specific figure. Purpose: hydroelectric / water.
PG&E Lake Almanor — operating (no recent NOAA PDF found)
Years: since 1953. Target: Lake Almanor, Butt Valley, and Mountain Meadows watersheds (Plumas, Lassen, Tehama). Means: ground-based AgI generators (2011 NOI: November–May). Money / grams: not published in the DWR RMS or the NOI text used here. No 2024–2026 Almanor Form 17-4 / 17-4A under the posted California filenames. DWR notes silver sampling in water, sediment, and fish at Lake Almanor (2000–2003) was far below toxic levels.
SMUD Upper American — listed (2020 report only)
DWR cites a Water Year 2020 SMUD / RHS Consulting winter report: streamflow up 13% over the basin and 20% in the primary target — the cited study’s estimates, not a current-season after-action. Current operator, means, grams, and budget are not confirmed in that paragraph.
San Joaquin and Carson / Walker — listed only
WMA economic assessments list a San Joaquin winter program (historic SCE among sponsors) and Carson/Walker snowpack work. Current-season operator, hours, grams, and budgets were not in the sources compiled for this map.
How ground generators work
California ground programs use two machines that do the same job in different ways: put microscopic AgI particles where wind will carry them into supercooled cloud.
Cloud Nuclei Generators (CNG)
SAWPA / NAWC describe a CNG as a propane-fueled unit that holds a silver iodide solution. When the unit is lit, the solution burns and the plume carries AgI particles into the air. SAWPA’s 2023–24 report says the solution is designed as a fast-acting nucleation agent (condensation-freezing) rather than slower contact nucleation — useful where mountain barriers are relatively narrow. Most SAWPA CNGs were operated by people at the host site (water-agency staff or landowners) after a meteorologist called for operations. One unit was run remotely. NAWC’s 2021 feasibility report recommended on the order of 20–25 grams of silver iodide per hour of CNG operation as a design rate — a recommendation, not a measured 2023–24 total.
AHOGS (Automated High Output Ground Seeding)
AHOGS units are remote flare trees. SAWPA and Santa Barbara reports describe a camera, battery, and cellular / modem control so a project meteorologist can ignite high-output AgI pyrotechnic flares from an operations center. Flares burn in place for a few minutes and release a dense burst of particles — intended for convective rain bands, where a continuous CNG plume may be too slow. Santa Barbara’s 2023–24 report says each AHOGS holds two masts and a total of 32 fast-acting flares, with spark arrestors over the flares. SAWPA used three AHOGS in 2023–24 (El Toro WD reservoir, East Orange County WD, and an EMWD booster); Santa Barbara used three active AHOGS for Twitchell (Mt. Lospe, Harris Grade, Berros Peak).
Aircraft seeding, when used, releases AgI from wing-tip solution generators or burn-in-place flares upwind of the target so crystals can grow and fall inside the watershed. TID’s page describes flying into the storm to test conditions, then igniting flares if the storm qualifies. SAWPA’s 2023–24 season was ground-only. Santa Barbara’s 2023–24 season was also ground-only; the county program design still includes aircraft in some years.
NOAA reports. It does not regulate.
The Weather Modification Reporting Act of 1972 (15 U.S.C. § 330 et seq.) and 15 CFR Part 908 require anyone conducting weather modification in the United States to file an initial report (Form 17-4) that NOAA must receive at least 10 days before activities start (15 CFR § 908.4), then file interim and final reports (Form 17-4A) afterward. That is prior notice, not a filing due within 10 days of any spraying. That reporting net is wider than winter cloud seeding. 15 CFR § 908.3(a)(3) expressly covers “modifying the solar radiation exchange of the earth or clouds, through the release of gases, dusts, liquids, or aerosols into the atmosphere.” EPA’s geoengineering pages point to the same rule. Make Sunsets’ 2023 Form 17-4 and the UW Hornet 2024CACARE-1 filing sit under that statute alongside AgI cloud-seeding 17-4s. GAO-26-108013 notes that finals are due no more than 45 days after activity ends, matching 15 CFR § 908.6. File both forms by email to weather.modification@noaa.gov. NOAA posts those filings on the Weather Modification Project Reports library page, usually within about two months after the end of the fiscal quarter. NOAA’s own FAQ says it does not research or conduct weather-modification experiments, and that it collects information but does not regulate cloud seeding.
GAO-26-108013 (February 2026) found that NOAA is not fully meeting its duty to maintain and share those reports. GAO reviewed a sample of the public archive and described it as incomplete, inconsistent, and unreliable: some submitted reports never appeared; the earliest record in the online database as of late 2025 was from 1999 even though the Act dates to the early 1970s; and four of ten states with publicly described 2021–2025 activities had some of those activities missing from NOAA’s database. GAO also estimated that more than half of filed reports likely have errors, including missing required information such as maps. NOAA agreed with GAO’s recommendations.
This map is therefore a compilation of reported activities from agency reports, DWR, and the NOAA reporting program. It may be incomplete. A structured 2000–2025 extract of NOAA PDFs is published on Zenodo (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.14925812) and described in Donohue & Lamb, arXiv:2505.01555. This compilation used that CSV (223 California rows; record updated 2025-07-10) to find NOAA filenames, then pulled newer 2026 PDFs from the NOAA library that post after the extract.
On the map, red is reserved for the newest posted after-action seeding — the latest month on a Form 17-4A or agency annual with modification days greater than zero. As of this compilation that is PG&E Mokelumne in November 2025 (Form 17-4A 2026CAMOKE-2: 1 day, 83 ground hours, 1,760 g silver iodide). A 2026 Form 17-4 initial (for example Tuolumne 2026WYUT-1) is prior notice only and stays the older color until an after-action report lists actual days.
What this map includes — and what it cannot
- santa-ana — 2023–24 operations; program ended July 10, 2025. 15 published generator sites + approximate watershed. No 2025–26 season.
- santa-barbara — 1981–present (NAWC/SBCWA); last confirmed seeded days early April 2024. 6 published AHOGS sites (3 active 2023–24). 2025CASB-1 noticed 2024–25; Dec 2024 17-4A reported 0 days. No 2026CASB found.
- kings — 1954–55–present; KRCD WY2025 operations ended Apr. 15, 2025. Approximate Pine Flat watershed. 2024WYKI-1 Form 17-4 on file; no 2025/2026 NOAA PDF found; WY2025 final not posted.
- tuolumne — TID since 1990; 2026WYUT-1 notices Nov. 1, 2025–Apr. 30, 2026. Aircraft AgI flares (WMI). 2026 initial is prior notice; no 17-4A of actual 2025–26 days posted.
- almanor — PG&E since 1953. Approximate target; no 2024–2026 Almanor NOAA PDF found under posted CA filenames.
- mokelumne — PG&E since 1953; red = most recent posted seeding (Nov. 2025). Approximate 170 sq mi target. 2026CAMOKE-1 (17-4) and 2026CAMOKE-2 (17-4A interim). No published generator coordinates.
- san-joaquin — Listed in WMA assessments; current season not confirmed here. Approximate area only
- american — DWR cites SMUD / RHS Water Year 2020 report. Approximate area only
- walker — Listed in WMA assessments; current season not confirmed here. Approximate CA-side box only
- make-sunsets — 2022–present (company); 2023 NOAA 17-4 on file; EPA §114 Apr. 2025. SO₂ balloons / cooling credits. HQ Box Elder, SD — not Alameda. Approximate Silicon Valley box only; exact lots unpublished. Separate from the UW Hornet sea-salt test.
- uw-hornet-mcb — March–April 2024 sprays; city rejected restart June 4, 2024. Sea-salt MCB spray on the USS Hornet, Alameda. NOAA 2024CACARE-1. Different actor, substance, and means from Make Sunsets.
- No California Form 17-4A with seeded days after November 2025 was posted. Mokelumne’s season is noticed through May 31, 2026; Tuolumne through Apr. 30, 2026. Those later months may still be in NOAA’s ~2-month-after-fiscal-quarter posting lag.
- No 2026CASB, 2026WYKI, or 2026 Almanor PDF was found on the NOAA oarcloud paths that hold the Mokelumne and Tuolumne 2026 files.
- Santa Barbara 2024–25: Form 17-4 exists; the only posted 17-4A (December 2024) is zero days. A full-season 17-4A / 2024–25 annual was not found.
- Kings WY2025 ended Apr. 15, 2025 per KRCD; the final report KRCD said it was waiting for is not in the NOAA filenames checked.
- NOAA Form 17-4 / 17-4A PDFs are the federal filings, but the public library table is incomplete (GAO-26-108013). This map is not a complete extract of every California 17-4 on file.
- Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.14925812 (updated 2025-07-10) has 223 California rows in cloud_seeding_us_2000_2025.csv. It includes 2025CASB-1, 2025WYUT-1, and 2025CAMOKE-1. 2026CAMOKE and 2026WYUT PDFs were posted after that extract and are cited from the NOAA library directly.
- Ground-generator coordinates are published for SAWPA 2023–24 (Table 2-2) and Santa Barbara AHOGS (Table 4-1) only. Mokelumne’s seven named 2024–25 burners have no published coordinates and are not plotted as pins.
- Amounts of AgI are included only where a Form 17-4A or agency annual published them (Mokelumne 17-4As; SAWPA 2023–24; Santa Barbara 2023–24).
- Rockets were not found in the California NOAA filings or agency reports used for this map; they are listed as a means filter with no features.
- Make Sunsets exact launch coordinates are not on the 2023 Form 17-4 or the EPA §114 letter. The South Bay box is an NPR-described region only. HQ is Box Elder, SD, not Alameda. Nevada launches named by the founder are off this California map.
- Stardust Solutions has no published California launch or test coordinates and is not plotted. EPA FAQ (July 2025): only Make Sunsets was then known as an active US SAI/MCB deployer; Stardust is R&D / test-prep. Do not invent a CA pin.
- This compilation does not invent other SAI companies. Public reporting on the commercial SAI field is essentially Make Sunsets (deploying SO₂ balloons) and Stardust (building an aircraft / particle system). Harvard SCoPEx and similar academic proposals are not commercial deployers and have no CA pin here.
- The UW Hornet pin uses published National Register coordinates for the museum ship, not a surveyed spray-nozzle location. Do not merge that pin with Make Sunsets.
- Dry ice and hygroscopic agents are mentioned generally by DWR for some aerial / supplemental work; no recent CA 17-4A compiled here named a dry-ice total, so they are not mapped as separate substances.
- The 2025 DWR RMS URL hosts the Water Plan Update 2023 Precipitation Enhancement strategy (October 2024 imprint). It does not include a machine-readable table of every current project.
Sources
- NOAA Weather Modification Project Reports (Forms 17-4 / 17-4A) — Federal reporting archive. File Form 17-4 at least 10 days before activity; file 17-4A afterward at weather.modification@noaa.gov. NOAA collects reports; it does not regulate or permit cloud seeding. Posts usually within ~2 months after the fiscal quarter.
- NOAA Form 17-4A 2026CAMOKE-2 (Mokelumne Nov–Dec 2025) — Newest posted CA after-action report with actual seeding: Nov 2025, 1 day, 83 ground hours, 1,760 g AgI.
- NOAA Form 17-4 2026CAMOKE-1 (Mokelumne 2025–26 initial) — Prior notice: Nov. 1, 2025–May 31, 2026. Seven ground generators at 21.5 g AgI/hour.
- NOAA Form 17-4 2026WYUT-1 (Upper Tuolumne 2025–26 initial) — Prior notice: Nov. 1, 2025–Apr. 30, 2026. Aircraft AgI flares (WMI). No 17-4A posted yet.
- NOAA 2025CASB-1 / FY25 Q2 17-4A (Santa Barbara Twitchell) — 2024–25 initial Dec. 1, 2024–Mar. 31, 2025; Dec 2024 interim reported 0 seeded days.
- 15 U.S.C. § 330 et seq. (Weather Modification Reporting Act of 1972) — Federal reporting statute. Implementing rules: 15 CFR Part 908.
- Structured US cloud seeding dataset 2000–2025 (Zenodo) — LLM extract of NOAA PDFs (record updated 2025-07-10); 223 California rows. Scientific Data / arXiv 2505.01555. 2026 NOAA PDFs are newer than this extract.
- Donohue & Lamb, arXiv:2505.01555 — Methods paper for the Zenodo dataset.
- CA DWR Precipitation Enhancement RMS (2025 URL / Water Plan Update 2023) — All CA projects geared to water supply or hydro. Statewide ~$5–7M/year; ~$20–40/AF. Winter orographic since early 1950s. NOI every five years.
- LA Times Daily Pilot — SAWPA $1.2M / DWR grant (Jan. 13, 2024) — Four-year Santa Ana pilot ~$1.2M; about half DWR grant; remainder split among five member agencies (Mosher).
- Noozhawk — Santa Barbara cloud seeding — ~$370k/year; Water Agency ~50%; ~nine purveyors; $80/AF agency/press claim.
- San Luis Obispo Tribune — Santa Barbara program — Same $370k / 50% county split as Noozhawk.
- Santa Barbara Independent — $370k (Dec. 29, 2022) — Board voted $370,000 for the season; NAWC contractor.
- Santa Barbara County File 18-00807 — 2018–19 NAWC agreement not to exceed $146,500.
- KRCD Weather Modification Program notice (2023–24) — Board-approved budget $475,597; KRWA and PG&E collaborators; ground + up to 30 hrs aircraft.
- CNBC — Western cloud seeding (Dec. 17, 2022) — TID program maximum budget $475,000; 3–5% runoff claim in that story.
- SF Chronicle — drought-era seeding costs — TID/MID about $165,000; PG&E 'couple of hundred thousand' and declined a specific amount.
- Turlock Journal — TID/MID ~$170k/year — Shared TID+MID cost about $170,000/year; WMI contractor. Program's 22nd year (~2012).
- SAWPA Annual Cloud Seeding Report 2023–24 — 15 sites, CNG/AHOGS description, 17,082 g + 640 g AgI.
- SAWPA program concludes (July 10, 2025) — Pilot ended after validation report; burn-scar suspension risk.
- Turlock Irrigation District cloud seeding — Aircraft AgI flares, Tuolumne watershed, since 1990, with MID.
- GAO-26-108013 — NOAA public database incomplete vs some state filings; NOAA does not regulate.
- GAO-26-108013 PDF — Four of ten states with 2021–2025 public activities had some activities missing from NOAA’s database.
- 15 CFR Part 908 — Weather Modification Reporting Act implementing rules.
- Santa Barbara / Twitchell CEQA MND (WMA) — County program since 1981; ground and aircraft AgI.
- Kings River JWM evaluations — Long-running KRCD program; NAWC since 2008.
- WMA economic assessment of western programs — Lists Almanor, Mokelumne, Tuolumne, San Joaquin, Kings, Carson/Walker, Santa Barbara, and others.
- 15 CFR § 908.3 — activities subject to reporting — Includes modifying solar radiation exchange through release of gases, dusts, liquids, or aerosols — not only cloud seeding.
- EPA news release — CAA §114 demand to Make Sunsets (Apr. 15, 2025) — Office of Air and Radiation information demand; SO₂ balloons and cooling credits.
- EPA Government Action (geoengineering) — Make Sunsets ~0.1 tons SO₂ as of May 2025; WMRA / 15 CFR 908.3 SRM reporting.
- EPA Frequent Questions (geoengineering) — As of July 2025, EPA was aware of only one private actor (Make Sunsets) that had actively deployed SAI or MCB in the United States; other private actors were developing technologies. US government not deploying SRM.
- Stardust Solutions — Company site; May 2026 papers on amorphous silica and particle dispersal. No CA launch map.
- Heatmap — Stardust $60M (Oct. 24, 2025) — Lowercarbon-led round; prior $15M seed; will not deploy until governments authorize (CEO).
- MIT Technology Review — Stardust (Dec. 10, 2025) — Ness Ziona HQ; aircraft + proprietary particles; contrasts with Make Sunsets balloons.
- POLITICO / E&E — Stardust $60M and contained aircraft tests — Delaware-incorporated; HQ outside Tel Aviv; ~$75M total; April 2026 in-plane tests at ~18 km described as contained, not free release.
- The Atlantic (Apr. 2, 2026) — Company: R&D not deployment; no outdoor tests planned until regulations.
- Wikipedia — Stardust Solutions — Secondary summary of incorporation, funding, and 2026 papers.
- Harvard / Keutsch Group — SCoPEx — Academic SRM experiment; not a commercial deployer; not on the CA map.
- EPA CAA §114 letter to Luke Iseman and Andrew Song — Addressed to 514 Americas Way #18412, Box Elder, SD 57719.
- NOAA Form 17-4 2023wmainitial (Make Sunsets / Cooling Earth) — Handwritten initial; balloon SAI; HQ Box Elder on the form.
- NOAA Form 17-4 2024CACARE-1 (UW / Hornet sea-salt study) — Field study of controlled-release sea salt aerosol plume; UW and SRI; Hornet host letter.
- Make Sunsets contact information — Published HQ: Box Elder, South Dakota — not Alameda.
- Make Sunsets FAQ — Company claims U.S. activity falls under the Weather Modification Act and yearly NOAA reporting.
- NPR — solar geoengineering, Make Sunsets and Hornet (Apr. 21, 2024) — Witnessed Silicon Valley-outskirts balloon launch and, separately, Hornet sea-salt spray.
- Inside Climate News — EPA targets Make Sunsets (Apr. 18, 2025) — Founder said balloons are released in California and Nevada; 2024 NOAA report not yet posted.
- City of Alameda statement (June 5, 2024) — Council unanimously rejected UW sea-salt studies on the USS Hornet.
- City of Alameda File 2024-4063 — Landlord consent item; 707 West Hornet Avenue; salt-water spray.
- USS Hornet Museum directions — 707 W Hornet Ave, Pier 3, Alameda.